Our Genereation, trip Girls, & American Girl DollComparison

by amandaanderton82 top top January 7, 2013

You are watching: Will journey girl clothes fit american girl

With 2 girls us are starting to get quite the collection of dolls! and also with them only being period 3 & 5 we most likely should slow our repertoire for awhile due to the fact that they aren’t even in prime doll playing period yet. But mommy can’t aid it sometimes. I choose making their clothes and doing your hair!

 I asked my mother the other day why ns never had American Girl Dolls cultivation up. Even in junior high ns was jealous of my girlfriend Shandi’s collection! She reminded me that i was much more into these dolls:


Anybody psychic these? i loved the Babysitters Club. At one time I had actually all the books and also many that the videos. I had actually a couple of of the Barbie dimension dolls and also then i think 4 or so of this 14 inch ones. I have actually no idea what occurred to them. It’s sad come think they probably finished up in a garage sale. I’ve determined I will certainly not let this occur to my children’s toys. The classic ones anyway.

A girlfriend of mine top top Facebook freshly posted the she to be frustrated through her girl’s ours Generation 18 inch doll due to the fact that the hair wasn’t manageable and also she was wondering if your was a far better brand the end there. So I thought I would do a little doll to compare of the 3 brands that us own.


In the picture above from left come right we have McKenna an American Girl that the Year Doll, Kelsey (a trip Girl), and also Holly (an our Generation) 

The ours Generation Dolls (Targets 18 inch doll brand) have a the majority of dolls to select from and also a great range of clothing and also accessories at the shortest prices the the 3 brands. The doll it s her runs about $23. However, ~ purchasing our very first Our Generation doll i am no satisfied v the quality. She is comparable to the size and also thickness that the American Girl Dolls, yet of the 3 her face is not as realistic and her plastic does not feel as sturdy together the other two brands. Yet my huge complaint is through her hair. Appropriate out of package I knew we would have problems with it once the hair come in a disarray to begin with, and also even after part brushing we might not seem to tame it. So for that reason we will not be buying another OG brand doll. However, ns cannot speak enough good things around the ours Generation accessories. This Christmas the girls obtained the RV/Camper from ours Generation as well as 3 the the horses and you yes, really can’t win the price! us will certainly be buying much more in the future. 

 Journey Girl Dolls (ToysRus Brand) have 6 dolls to choose from. They run around $32. Their faces are beautiful done, and also their eyes space so pretty that does not bother me the they carry out not open and shut. The dolls have actually rooted hair similar to the OG dolls but it is much simpler to take care of and even after gift loved by a three year old i am may be to obtain the hair ago looking great! The dolls room skinnier 보다 the OG & AG dolls. That really is the only trouble I have actually with them and only due to the fact that it is tough to share clothes with the OG & AG dolls. The JG garments are too tight or carry out not to the right at every on the AG & OG and also the AG & OG space too big for the JG. Yet we prefer the outfits because that the journey Girls because they are great quality and very modern in style. We room able to put some of the AG garments on them and also the girl don’t mental if it’s a small baggy. Unlike the AG & OG Dolls journey Girls are just stuffed from the waste down, so i think the little sleeveless tops and dresses look more realistic on them because there is no exposed fabric at the shoulders. So because that $10 much more than the our Generation brand i would absolutely recommend trip Girls as your girl’s first 18 customs doll or in addition to your American Girl Dolls. Great Quality in ~ a great Price! we love lock so lot we now have all 6! i should also mention that ns really choose the trip Girls accessories as well. We own the loft bed the reminds me a small of the one the American Girl offers and also the girls love it, i think my only thing is that the chairs that come with it it seems to be ~ on the tiny side and don’t watch size ideal for any kind of of the dolls, yet my girls don’t really care.

 American Girl Dolls have a million to select from, and also there is just something therefore appealing about them. I loved acquisition my oldest to the American Girl ar in Chicogo ago in November, and I’m looking front to taking my youngest sometime this year to let her experience it too.


American Girl location Chicago in November with our girlfriend Janet, Emma & Audrey (Me and Moo space on the right)

The prices are outrageous! but the high quality is outstanding and also for that factor we are lifelong American Girl fans. I think yes, really my only complaint (other than the price) is ns actually like the rooted hair (like journey Girls) as opposed come the wig. Yet the wig is much fuller, which ns think is necessary due to the fact that of the lot of hair that is lost while brushing.

 We bought an American Girl doll end the summer at a garage sale for $10. She hair to be pretty messed up and also had some bald spots, but for approximately $20 I had the ability to buy wig turn off of Ebay and after watching some video tutorials top top YouTube i was may be to replace the wig myself. If ns were to execute this again i think I would certainly compare part wig brands that are obtainable to see if ns can find a fuller wig but in its entirety we to be happy with the new look and so for $30 we obtained a good deal. Also earlier in December us were maybe to obtain Marie Grace and also Cecile (two of the AG historic characters) for a mere $50 consisting of their accessories. ( i think it was $60 each once shipping was included but it was a $124 value each!). A friend of mine referred to as me one morning and told me the the Today show as walking to be revealing a coupon code deal for American Girl.

See more: Eli5: Why Are Read And Read Spelled The Same As Read, Eli5: Why Is Read Spelt The Same As Read

Before that part of the display aired I determined to check out some details online and also it turned the end that the password had already been posted due to the fact that it had aired in earlier time area already! i was maybe to gain the deal, but a few of mine friends that tried after ~ me were not. The dolls were marketed out even prior to the portion of the show was aired here! yet the suggest of all this is that periodically you can find a deal!


And that’s mine review! expect it was advantageous in helping you decide which doll you’d choose to buy! If girlfriend have any questions or have anything you’d favor to add comment below!