When choosing in between a wooden pencil and a mechanically pencil, both have actually their strengths and weaknesses. This overview will assist you know the differences and where they are best suited. First, you require to know a bit about the yes, really pencils.We begin with a brief advent to wood pencils and also who renders the ideal ones, varieties of mechanical pencils, and also examples the the ideal ones.Finally, we end up off v a considerable roundup that compares wooden and also mechanical pencils when offered in their various applications.

You are watching: Why are wooden pencils better than mechanical

*
Regarding the Pencil command Grade Hardness Chart, H describes the Hardness and B to Blackness that the lead, and also F is Firm. H graded leads are really smudge-resistant and produce spicy lines. B command is softer and smoother come write and also draw with yet smudges easily.9H – 6H This is a solid lead and a an extremely light grey; the is not typically used for writing or drawing yet for committed things such as map-making.5H – 3H This is a really hard lead, and also it is supplied by experts for technical drawing and also by students and mathematicians because that charts and also Graphs.2H & H This is a hard lead, and again, that is provided for technical drawing and also mathematics.F & HB This is tool lead and also is usually offered for writing and also drawing lines. The is hard enough to not smudge easily and also dark sufficient so the it can be read without difficulty.B – 3B This is a soft lead provided for freehand drawing; it have the right to be offered for writing, yet it smudge relatively quickly, so that is not supplied as generally as HB.4B – 9B This is a very soft dark lead mostly used through artists because that drawing and sketching. 9 B is so soft and crumbly the it is right used.Staedtler and Mitsubishi in reality make a 12B and a 10B graded pencil; if you would favor to know an ext about these, then inspect out The finish Guide come The Darkest Pencil Lead for much more information,

2. Who provides The finest Wooden Pencils?

With so plenty of different pencil manufacturers, it deserve to be confusing as to who renders the best wooden pencils. There space not plenty of quality pencil manufacturers left in the U.S except Dixon Ticonderoga and also General Pencils.Germany and Japan room the powerhouses for production wooden pencils and also have a long background of creating pencils that room of the highest quality.Most the the finest quality pencils room made from incense-cedar lumber as it is softwood straightforward to sharpen and does no blunt the chisels of pencil sharpeners. Although Caran d’Ache, the luxury products manufacture, supplies other types of woods such as beechwood. If you desire to know more about the various pencil manufacturers and their pencil ranges, inspect out The Ultimate wood Pencil brand Guide. Once you have chosen her perfect pencil, climate you need a good quality pencil sharpener. The German manufacturer Kum is widely concerned as make the ideal pencil sharpeners in the world. Check out The Ultimate guide to Kum Pencil Sharpeners for much more information.

2.1. Blackwing

*
 Check Price and Reviews top top AmazonBlackwing is perhaps among the best-known and iconic high quality pencil brand names and also is famed for the Blackwing 602 pencil. It was an initial launched in 1934 by the Eberhard Faber Pencil Company. It was discontinued in the 19190’s by Newell Rubbermaid, that then owned the Blackwing brand name.It looked as though the Blackwing 602 was set to be consigned to the history books till The Blacking Brand name was purchase by the California Cedar assets Company in 2008. It was relaunched under their Palomino brand name as the Blackwing Palomino 602. They have dropped the Palomino surname from their Blackwing pencil range.As well as the Blackwing 602 likewise makes a wide variety of pencils, including minimal editions, a long point pencil sharpener, and also the Blackwing suggest Guard.

2.2. Caran d’Ache

*
Check Price and also Reviews ~ above AmazonThe luxury brand Caran d’Ache room renowned because that the high quality of their wood pencils. Unlike many other manufacturers through their pencils room made that beech hardwood or pine timber from Swiss forests.Not surprisingly, they called their pencils Caran d’Ache Swiss hardwood pencils, and they space HB command hardness grade, however they do lug a hefty price tag.
*
Check Price and Reviews on AmazonIf you desire a pencil that is both rare and also exotic, climate the Les Crayons de la Maison Caran d’Ache ed. N°7 fits the invoice nicely. That is a collection o 4 HB pencils that are made native “noble woods.”Polychrome SipoStreaked White BirchAfrican AssamelaGrey LimbaThey also make a scented variation of these one-of-a-kind edition pencils, yet you will be parting with roughly $30.00 for simply 4 pencils.

2.3. Faber-Castell

*
Check Price and Reviews ~ above AmazonFaber-Castell is just one of the world’s biggest manufacturers of writing equipment and can trace its roots earlier to 1761 as soon as Casper Faber, a carpenter native Nuremberg in Germany, very first started the company.Today Faber-Castell provides a wide selection of wood pencils, however they room most famed for the Faber-Castell 9000 pencil, very first launched in 1905. As you would expect from a quality pencil, it is do from cedarwood, and the graphite core is bonded to the lumber of the pencil, making it particularly break-resistant.Faber-Castell 9000 pencils have the classic green colored barrel and also are available in 16 degrees of hardness indigenous 6H come 8B. This provides them appropriate for drafting, drawing, writing and sketching. They are widely regarded as the best graphite pencils in the world.

2.4. Basic Pencils

*
Check Price and also Reviews on AmazonGeneral pencils are among the USA’s earliest pencil companies; it started in 1860 as the American Pencil agency and changed its surname to The basic Pencil Company. They do a wide variety of pencils yet are ideal known because that the Generals Semi-Hex pencil.It is made from cedarwood, and also its most notable attribute is the although that is hexagonally shaped, the directly edges have actually been rounded off, make it much more comfortable come hold. Lock are available in five degrees of hardness.#1/B Extra Soft#2/HB Soft#2 ½/F Medium#3/H Hard#4/2H Extra HardThe Generals Semi-Hex pencil is widely provided by students and also office workers.

2.5. Mitsubishi

*
Check Price and also Reviews on AmazonThe Japanese Mitsubishi Pencil firm started life in 1887 as the Masaki Pencil Manufacturing company and changed its name to Mitsubishi Pencil firm after the second world war. Their an initial wooden pencil to be the Mitsubishi 9800, i m sorry is quiet going strong today together their entry-level pencil.But the pencil the Mitsubishi is famous for and sought ~ by pencil enthusiasts is the Mitsubishi Hi-Uni pencil. That was an initial launched in 1966, and also what makes this pencil so distinctive is the high quality of that is graphite core.The graphite and clay that make up the core are processed in the manufacturing facility so the the particles are ground and filtered to the exact tolerance and also then uniformly mixed, creating superb pencil lead the is highly resistant come breaking.HI Uni Pencils are accessible in 15 levels of hardness native 10B come 10H.

2.6. Staedtler

*
Check Price and also Reviews top top AmazonStaedtler is one of Europes best pencil manufacturers, through the Staedtler Norris and Tradition pencils being your entry-level pencil. These are the mainstay pencil for European schools and offices but are not as well-known in America, overcame by general Pencils and Ticonderoga.Where Staedtler comes right into its very own right is with its premium high quality Mars Lumograph 100 drawing pencils. They are obtainable In 24 levels of hardness native which are;12B, 11B, 10B, 9B, 8B, 7B, 6B, 5B, 4B, 3B, 2B, B, HB, F, H, 2H, 3H, 4H, 5H, 6H, 7H, 8H, 9H, 10HThe pencils have a distinct lead formulation that offers a metallic luster in the harder lead grades and super bonded lead v a high rest resistance. These pencils are ideal for skilled graphic and also artistic users, and they are ideal for drawing, hatching, writing, and also sketching,

2.7. Tombow

*
Check Price and Reviews top top AmazonTombow is one more Japanese powerhouse in the pencil industry. Established in 1913, they have actually a call for do high-quality pencils. The Tombow 8900 pencil is their entry-level pencil, yet many feel the this is far superior to plenty of U.S entry-level pencils.The pencil they space really recognized for is their premium top quality Tombow Mono 100 pencil, with countless people saying that this is the best wooden pencil. It absolutely is a great pencil and also is a worthy competitor to the Blackwing 602 and also the Mitsubishi Hi-Uni pencils for the title of the finest wooden pencil.

2.8. Ticonderoga

*
Check Price and Reviews top top AmazonIf girlfriend live in the U.S, then the opportunities are that you provided a Ticonderoga #2 wood pencil at school or college. Dixon Ticonderoga can trace that is roots back to 1812 as soon as Joseph Dixon do his an initial wooden pencil.In 1913 the Ticonderoga #2 pencil was launched; its classic yellow barrel is do from cedarwood, and it has actually a distinctive graphite main point formula that gives the pencil the smooth writing performance.Dixon Ticonderoga is America’s biggest pencil manufacture and also sells a staggering 1.5 billion Pencils a Year.For much more information around Dixon Ticonderoga, check out our Comprehensive overview to Dixon Ticonderoga Pencils.

3. Types of mechanical Pencil

A pencil that is not wood-cased and also its command is cost-free from that is casing is taken into consideration a mechanically pencil. There room three different varieties of mechanical pencils which are general purpose, drafting, and also clutch pencils. Check out our Top 10 Drafting and Mechanical Pencils for an ext information.Before you deserve to compare wood pencils against mechanical first, you need to understand what each kind of pencil is used.

3.1. Basic Purpose

A general-purpose mechanically pencil usually has actually 0.5mm or 0.7mm lead, and they are mainly used because that writing, sketching, and geometry. It can additionally be referred to as an automatically pencil, clicky pencil, dual knock pencil, or propelling pencil.The finer 0.5mm mechanical pencil is better suited for creating sharper lines in maths and geometry, although it have the right to be used for writing and also note-taking.The 0.7mm mechanically pencil is the most common lead size for mechanical pencils as the currently are similar with a fine suggest pen. Castle are likewise ideal for drawing and also sketching, and why there is a more comprehensive choice of lead grades available.It is daunting to say which the best general-purpose mechanical pencil is as they can selection in price from a few cents because that Bic pencils up to hundreds of dollars from deluxe brands such together Graf Von Faber Castell.
*
Check Price and also Reviews top top AmazonBut if girlfriend are in search of the many popular, friend cannot walk wrong with a Japanese-made mechanical pencil. Pentel makes terrific pencils, and the Pentel twist Erase is among their most popular it has a broad barrel with a really comfortable latex-free grip, and also the jumbo eraser at the end that friend twist out takes its surname from.

3.2. Drafting Pencil

Drafting pencils are skilled quality mechanically pencils mostly designed for technical drawing, return they have the right to be used for writing, drawing, sketching, etc. They room usually obtainable in 0.3mm, 0.5mm, 0.7mm, and 0.9mm lead diameters. Castle can also be referred to as technical pencils.Drafting pencils usually have a longer lead sleeve 보다 a general-purpose mechanical pencil. The advantage of this is the it works better with straight edges such as rulers and squares.As fine as having actually a much longer lead sleeve drafting pencils often have extra attributes such together a integrated lead class indicator. 
*
Check Price and Reviews ~ above AmazonThe Japanese-made Ohto at sight Promecha PM-1500P is thought about by countless to it is in the finest drafting pencil in the world. It is an aluminum pencil packed through features, consisting of a built-in lead class indicator indigenous B come H.Underneath the push button is an eraser v a clearing pin, and also the pocket clip have the right to be removed if that is her preference.The lead sleeve have the right to be fully retracted or set in 1mm increments up to 5mm completely extended by transforming the pencil grip.You can set how much lead is dispensed with each press of the push switch from 0.2mm up to 2.0mm. The Ohto at sight Promecha PM-1500P important is an exceptional mechanical pencil.

3.3. Clutch Pencil

Clutch pencils space the oldest kind of mechanically pencil and are additionally referred to together lead holders. They differ from mechanical pencils since their lead is not advanced via a push-button mechanism through a sleeve.Instead, the command is organized in location by a spring-loaded clutch mechanism; upon pushing the push button, this operates the clutch opened the jaws and permitting the result in drop freely from the pencil till the push button is released. As soon as the push button is released, the clutch device closes, and the jaws organize the lead firmly in place.This kind of clutch pencil is recognized as a fall clutch pencil as the command drops openly upon pressing the push button.There is likewise another form of clutch pencil i m sorry is well-known as one incremental clutch pencil. V these pencils, you must keep pushing the push button to breakthrough the lead.Clutch pencils are predominately provided by artists and usually have actually 2mm lead, although some clutch pencils room made by Faber-Castell and Worther that use 3.15mm lead. And also 5.6mm clutch pencils made by e+m and Koh-I-Noor.Clutch pencils normally use a darker softer command to attract with however there room colored leads obtainable check out our Ultimate overview to Colored mechanical Pencil Lead for an ext information.
*
Check Price and Reviews on AmazonThe Faber Castell TK9400 clutch pencils are one of the most renowned 2.0mm autumn clutch pencils, a firm favourite of artists because that drawing and also sketching. The lead grade is marked on the barrel, i beg your pardon is really useful when you have actually several pencils with various lead grades.As for incremental clutch pencils, the Staedtler 925 25 2.0mm are widely regarded as the best clutch pencil of this type. Castle are made for the Japanese industry who room crazy around their mechanically pencils and are usually significant with 925 25 20 Japan uneven you buy a european model.

4. Wood Pencils V mechanical Pencils

Both wooden and mechanical pencils have benefits and disadvantages; however, they have to not be assumed of together something come be provided exclusively. Mechanically pencils were never meant to change wooden pencils yet were draft to produce consistent, accurate, precise lines. I m sorry is daunting to accomplish with a wooden pencil.

4.1. Drawing

*
Wooden pencils space predominantly used for drawing; the pencil’s tip can be sharpened in various ways to offer other effects. Depending on the form of sharpener, the cone deserve to be sharpened to more comprehensive or smaller sized diameters with lengthy sharp clues or more rounded duller points.When artists are very first learning exactly how to draw, they space taught to use the fine allude for much more detailed work and also angle the pencil once they must create more comprehensive strokes or shading.There room some defect to utilizing wooden pencils because that drawing. The key ones space that the pencil demands to it is in sharpened fairly frequently, and also as girlfriend sharpen it, the pencil becomes smaller and smaller. When a pencil becomes too small to hold in hand comfortably, many human being will use a pencil extender. Inspect out our guide, The peak 10 Pencil Extenders, for more information.Many artists, though, perform use mechanical pencils as soon as drawing; among the main reasons is that a mechanical pencil is much easier to grip and much more comfortable to hold with a continuous weight and feel. Mechanically pencils give artists the capability to select a mechanically pencil that suits their personal preferences. Perhaps they prefer broader barrels or more heavier pencils v metallic barrels.The various other reason that human being use mechanically pencils for drawing is that they produce a consistent line width. This can be essential for thorough work and sketching fine lines.The diameter the the lead have the right to be selected according to your needs and also the pencil will develop a regular line without the require for sharpening.There space some disadvantages to utilizing mechanical pencils because that drawing. The main ones space that with a consistent mechanical pencil, you cannot execute sketching or shading. However, a particular kind of mechanically pencil dubbed a clutch pencil has actually either 2.0mm or 5.6mm leads best for smooth, also shading.The other drawback v mechanical pencils is the the leader are an ext brittle and also the an extremely thin diameter leader break easily. Over there is additionally the possibility of getting a lead jam in the command pipe, and you will should use a clearing pin to complimentary it.

4.2. Technical drawing & Plotting

Wooden pencils room not normally used for technological drawing, plotting, and also map-making together the reminder of the pencil requires continuous sharpening and cannot produce specific line widths. However, their points deserve to be sharpened to a allude finer than that which have the right to be completed with a mechanical pencil and also are still offered by part professionals.For architects, draughtsmen, and cartographers, this is wherein mechanical pencils and also professional drafting pencils come right into their very own right.With these species of pencils, you can consistently produce specific lines that a certain width. You have total control that the line width and also how dark that is.
*
Pentel Orenz 0.2mm mechanically PencilCheck Price and also Reviews on AmazonThis is accomplished by the diameter of the lead and also the graphite hardness. Mechanical pencils and also lead is available in 0.2mm, 0.3mm, 0.4mm, 0.5mm, 0.7mm, 0.9mm, 1.15mm, 1.13mm, 2.0mm, 3.2, 5.2mm, and also 5.6mm. Yes, 0.2mm lead really does exist. Pentel provides the Pentel Orenz 0.2mm mechanical pencil and also a 0.2mm lead to go through it.The graphite hardness determines exactly how dark the pencil will certainly be this is where mechanical pencils space at a disadvantage to wood pencils. The command is bonded with a wood pencil, i.e., glued to the hardwood casing, making that stronger and also highly break-resistant.With mechanical pencils, the lead comes out of a sleeve v no protection and is susceptible to break under push where that comes out of the sleeve. Since of this, mechanical pencil lead is available in fewer levels of hardness than wood pencils.The smaller and larger diameters of pencil lead are usually obtainable with a smaller variety of graphite qualities to pick from:Wooden Pencils as much as 24 levels of hardness indigenous 12B – 10HMechanical Pencils 0.3mm commonly 5 levels of hardness 2H, H, HB, B, and 2BMechanical Pencils 0.5mm commonly 9 degrees of hardness 4H – 4BMechanical Pencils 0.7mm commonly 9 degrees of hardness 4H – 4BMechanical Pencils 0.9mm typically 4 degrees of hardness H, HB, B, and also 2BThere is likewise one various other thing precious bearing in mind as soon as using a mechanical pencil, and that is if you constantly host the pencil the same way, then the lead will certainly wear top top one side, providing a slight variation in the heat width.It is great practice to revolve the pencil every now and again as you room using it to ensure that the lead wears under evenly and also keeps a continual diameter. However, one mechanical pencil overcomes this problem, and also that is the Uni Kuru Toga, the world’s an initial self-sharpening mechanically pencil.Some very clever techies in Japan spent number of years emerging a clutch device that instantly rotates the pencils lead each time you remove the pencil pointer from the composing surface.Check out our guide, The ideal Mechanical Pencil Leads, for much more information on Kuru Toga lead and to see the 5 finest mechanical pencil lead refills.

4.3. Writing

*
When it comes to the writer, the is purely under to personal preference for writing v a wood pencil or a mechanically pencil. Many human being prefer a wooden pencil once writing, together a mechanical pencil deserve to feel a little soulless. Return you can buy a mechanical pencil made out of a details material or with a rubberized grip for a bit more comfort.If you space writing a lot, the main advantage a mechanical pencil has over a wood one is the it will write for quite a lengthy time before changing the lead. Vice versa, a pencil obviously requires sharpening native time to time.

The best Mechanical Pencil lead Diameters and also Grades for Writing

HB 0.7mm is the most popular size and also lead grade for a mechanically pencil offered for writing. It is stronger than 0.5mm and is much better suited if you space a little bit on the heavy-handed side. The is dark sufficient to it is in seen clearly when composed on paper. As well as being hard enough so that it does no smudge and also can be easily erased.B & 2B are additionally popular together they space smoother to write with and also leaves a darker mark on the paper. The fence is that because they are a softer lead, they are much more prone come smudging.H & 2H room the more difficult grades; they leave a lighter silvery note on the paper and deserve to be quickly erased. The fence is the they deserve to be a little scratchier come use and the lighter note is not as easy to read.Outside of these ranges, the B qualities are too soft writing and also smudge an extremely easily; they are mostly used for illustration by artists. The H qualities are too hard, and the marks space pretty light, so experts such together draughtsmen and cartographers use these grades.

Pencil Cases, Pockets, and also Backpacks

If you require to lug a pencil approximately with you in one of two people a backpack, pencil case, or even your pocket. Then a mechanical pencil is the better option as the command is safeguarded inside the pencil’s body. No spicy points that can break or jab right into you.However, there is a straightforward solution to safeguard the guideline of your pencil: a pencil cap. Inspect out our post on the 7 best pencil hat to protect points for much more information.

4.4. I m sorry is far better for The environment Wooden Pencils or mechanical Pencils?

If you take the pencils lead or graphite main point out that the equation together they both usage a combination of lead and clay to make it. Assuming that you compose the exact same amount of text, both wooden and mechanical pencils will usage the exact same amount of lead to produce the text.This pipeline the body of the pencil regarding which has actually a more far-ranging impact ~ above the environment.

Mechanical Pencils

Mechanical pencils usage a particular amount of oil to develop them, nevertheless of even if it is they space plastic or metal.At the end of your life, they are usually walking to finish up in landfills together they will be complicated or impossible in the situation of plastic-bodied mechanically pencils to recycle.On the add to side, with a mechanically pencil, girlfriend only must replace the lead once it has been manufactured.

Wooden Pencils

Wooden pencils take much less energy to develop than mechanical pencils, and a fully grown tree can create thousands that pencils.Wood is sustainable, so a new tree deserve to be planted to replace a tree used for making pencils.Over time the finish of a discarded wood pencil will ultimately compost down.On the face, wooden pencils are much more environmentally friendly than mechanical pencils; over there is one big caveat, though. Because that example, if you take a Blackwing Pencil (sorry, Blackwing, I understand other manufacturers do the exact same thing), The cedar hardwood is get an impressive in either California or Oregon. That is climate transported come Japan, wherein the pencil main point is made and bonded to the wood prior to being shipped back to the U.S. The erasers and also ferrules room made in Vietnam and also then sent to the U.s, wherein the Blacking pencils room assembled. The is a most air miles because that something as an easy as a wood pencil.

4.5. Carpenters Pencils

*
 Check Price and also Reviews top top AmazonWhen it comes to carpenters’ pencils, wood pencils victory hands down. The lead the is used in mechanical pencils is not robust sufficient to note the hardwood without breaking. Since the lead is external inspection to the wood, the is a many stronger and highly break-resistant.An plain pencil can be used by carpenters and also joiners, yet they commonly use a particular form of pencil referred to as a carpenters pencil. They have a larger rectangle-shaped body that stays clear of them native rolling around. Carpenters pencils are used by tradesmen to note rough surfaces such as timber or stone.

4.6. I beg your pardon Pencils space Cheaper to use, wood or Mechanical?

From a completely cost suggest of view, over there is most likely not a many in it, and also it relies on how much you usage your pencil.If you are using a pencil a most the time, then mechanical pencils are more than likely cheaper in the long run as you are just replacing the leads. Castle are additionally a lot much more convenient through no sharpening and also easier to carry around.

See more: 2007 Pontiac G6 Brake Lights Stay On, G6 Brake Lights Possessed

4.7 i m sorry Pencils are better for youngsters Wooden or Mechanical?

*
Young kids who room preschoolers or kindergarteners are far better at making use of jumbo-sized wood pencils together their hands have not developed the motor skills to organize the pencil. Us recommend starting them off v a jumbo-sized round barreled pencil. Then, as they go into kindergarten, moving them on come a jumbo-sized triangular pencil helps promote a appropriate tripod grip.This is considered by many teachers to it is in the best way to host a pencil.For more information, inspect out The 10 finest Pencils for Kindergarteners.As the children get older, many favor a mechanically pencil for daily writing and also sketching, but children have different needs indigenous a mechanical pencil 보다 adults; inspect out the 6 ideal mechanical pencils for children to uncover out more.You may additionally be interested to discover that there are countless other species of pencils,s not simply wooden and mechanical pencils. In fact, there room 12 various types.Check the end The can be fried Pencil species Guide for an ext info.