"Criminal Minds" to be no stranger to intense, frightening, and also downright mental scenes once it was still ~ above the air. The police procedural crime drama supplied us v 15 seasons of action — and a rumored upcoming 16th — together the agents that the FBI"s Behavioral evaluation Unit (BAU) worked to understand the psychic of violent criminal in the hope the their psychological insights might aid bring this killers to justice. Though the cast changed over the years, fans concerned know and love the team, i beg your pardon usually consisted of agents Aaron Hotchner (Thomas Gibson), Jennifer "JJ" Jareau (A.J. Cook), Derek Morgan (Shemar Moore), Spencer Reid (Matthew Gray Gubler), and also Penelope Garcia (Kirsten Vangsness), among a few other part-timers.

You are watching: When does prentiss come back from the dead

One the the later additions to the BAU to be Emily Prentiss (Paget Brewster), the supervisory distinct agent who replaced Elle Greenaway (Lola Glaudini) in Season 2. Brewster"s Prentiss took awhile to meld with the rest of the established team. Her political connections initially rubbed Hotch the dorn way, and her really presence in ~ the BAU also threatened his job at one point, despite she ultimately proved herself and won anyone over v her brilliant insights and courageous action in the field. Prentiss is beloved amongst the fandom for her intelligence, leadership, and also general butt-kicking abilities — she may be ranks together the team"s second-best unsub tackler, best after Shemar Moore"s Derek Morgan. In spite of all those respectable achievements, however, she absolutely had her fair re-publishing of cringey moments on the long-running procedural.

Let"s challenge it: "Criminal Minds" probed some dark and also disturbing territory, cross the line with fans on much more than one occasion. Although Prentiss had her hand in plenty of these kinds of cringey moments, it"s actually an act of deception the left the viewers feeling many betrayed. Let"s take it a look at a Prentiss scene the went too much for even the many hardened fans.

In Season 6, Prentiss learns the a violent fugitive named Ian Doyle has actually escaped from prison and also is likely looking to kill her. Doyle sends an ominous flower come Prentiss" door and also leaves a creepy voicemail on her phone, i beg your pardon prompts she to enter hiding. We uncover that when Prentiss was working for Interpol, she was component of a team who functioned to catch terrorists. Doyle to be personally influenced by her initiatives when his boy was apparently murdered by the group. We additionally learn the Prentiss brought out a partnership with Doyle that offered as component of her cover, making the a fool 2 times over and breaking his psychotic heart in the process. Together Bill suitably points out in "Kill bill Vol. 2," "There are results to break the love of murdering bastard."

The season escalates as soon as Prentiss decides to go after Doyle alone, due to the fact that he"s started murdering people connected with his Interpol case. She eventually tracks him down, just to it is in abducted, held hostage, and also tortured by Doyle therefore he have the right to extemporize in ~ length about his motivations and also exposit a little of deep Prentiss history. As soon as he realizes Prentiss staged his son"s death, he i do not care enraged and starts attacking her simply as the BAU reaches Doyle"s hideout. Doyle stabs Prentiss in the stomach before disappearing, and also the BAU find Prentiss apparently bleeding to death on the floor.

The BAU hold a funeral for Prentiss — only she"s no really dead. It turns out: Prentiss faked her death to store her team safe, since Doyle was still top top the loose. The show deploys rather a little of handwaving to explain just exactly how Prentiss pulled off this deception — particularly considering the fact that she collection out to deceive the members of a crack investigative team prefer the BAU. To even accept Prentiss" successful ruse and also her same unlikely return ~ Doyle is encountered in Season 7, "Criminal Minds" requires an uncommonly high level the suspension of disbelief — and that"s part of what irked every the fans.

See more: Reason To Be Late Starting With E, Rational Dissenters In Late Eighteenth

The other component of this storyline that renders fans cringe is the effect Prentiss" deception has actually on the remainder of the BAU, which any long-time viewer will certainly tell you is pretty lot a family. 

Her teammates are rightfully traumatized, and Reid also takes a few episodes to acquire over the lie ~ she returns to the group, despite they at some point patch things up. Maybe Prentiss to be justified in wanting to safeguard her colleagues from Doyle, a proven killer v no qualms around targeting law enforcement. Considering every the trauma this team had currently endured through Season 6, however, forcing them to confront the death of a beloved team member most likely wasn"t worth the cost. Let"s not forget that by this point in the series, Gideon (Mandy Patinkin) has currently left, and also Hotch has lost his wife to the Reaper. Reid, who takes Prentiss" betrayal the hardest, has had actually to overcome PTSD after gift captured and held by serial killer Tobias Hankel (James van Der Beek). The last thing this crew required was a dead Emily Prentiss ~ above their collective conscience, and for a few in-show months, that"s what she provided them.