The alternate title is ‘why walk Sirius Black imply a an enig Keeper switch for the Fidelius Charm?’

“Hey, Cy, are you certain this is the ideal question? Wasn’t this reply already? Why would certainly we need to discuss this?” Alfred blinked up in ~ the write-up title. He then turned his confused gaze in ~ Cyrus.

“Oh, is the so? and also what’s the price then?” Cyrus replied.

“Well, Sirius Black, from the harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling, want to switch the secret Keeper come Peter Pettigrew because that the Fidelius Charm,” Alfred began, “‘cause he assumed that this to be the perfect arrangement to cheat the Dark lord Voldemort and keep James, Lily and also Harry Potter safe.”

He continued, “He believed that no one would ever suspect Peter and also that everyone would think the he, Sirius, would be the an enig Keeper for his finest friend and his family, no questions asked. This setup would have operated too, if Peter hadn’t betrayed his friends.” that frowned in ~ that.

You are watching: Sirius black and the secret keeper

“Hm,” was Cyrus’ noncommittal response. “Anyone who has read the publications should understand that, which is why that should have actually been evident that the short article title was not talking around that.”

“Eh? What’s it around then?”

“This is actually pertained to the previous article about the Fidelius Charm.”

“Uh, was the the one wherein we talked about on whether or no it was possible to do the an enig Keeper involuntarily expose the secret he or she is hiding favor by being provided Veritaserum or having actually someone usage Legilimency on that or her?” Alfred asked.

“Yes. Let’s say, because that instance, the that’s actually true, unless there’s evidence to prove otherwise, then why would Black need to suggest a secret Keeper switch to make sure that the Potters will really be safeguarded under the Fidelius Charm?”

Alfred blinked, not obtaining the question. “Huh?” was his eloquent reply.

Cyrus rolling his eyes. “Look, compare Sirius Black and Pettigrew. I beg your pardon of lock is stronger? If anyone can withstand gift hurt through Voldemort, if anyone can shot to withstand Veritaserum or Legilimency, it would certainly be Sirius and also not Peter.”

“Yeah, but, isn’t that why Sirius would certainly be the decoy? lock could record him and also do whatever they want however they won’t have the ability to get the secret from Sirius ‘cause he doesn’t recognize anything and the mystery will it is in safe through Peter, the real mystery Keeper.”

“Yes, yes,” Cyrus waved this away. “Look, the worst case scenario is that the mystery Keeper will acquire captured. If that human is actually Black, we already know that he’d fairly die 보다 betray the Potters and also reveal the mystery of your whereabouts.

“So,” the continued, “with the said, what’s maintaining Black from gift the mystery Keeper instead of having actually to transport that duty to Peter Pettigrew? We currently know that black color is 100% trusted so the Potters have nothing to worry about with regards to your safety also if Sirius gets recorded by the fatality Eaters.

“Sirius black color won’t voluntarily or willingly reveal the an enig unless they usage Veritaserum and Legilimency ~ above him, i beg your pardon is out of his control and which would make that involuntarily reveal the mystery he’s hiding. However that’s exactly the suggest here.”

“What perform you mean?” Alfred asked.

“If such things have the right to render the Fidelius Charm invalid, then it’s pretty much useless. The minute the mystery Keeper is captured, and you have to think about that as a possibility due to the fact that no one in the light side is for sure from Voldemort, then the mystery would be revealed the minute they use the previously mentioned methods uneven it’s actually impossible for the mystery to be revealed involuntarily.”

“Wait, friend mean, if, for example, Peter was loyal and also if he’s the secret Keeper and he’s captured, climate they deserve to make him disclose the mystery involuntarily. So, it won’t issue who the mystery Keeper is, be it Sirius or Peter, if something favor Veritaserum and Legilimency have the right to make them involuntarily reveal the secret?” Alfred realized.

“Yes, exactly. So, unless it’s actually impossible for the Fidelius Charm come be damaged involuntarily, that is to say, if the mystery Keeper doesn’t have to reveal the mystery willingly and also voluntarily, then the Fidelius Charm is useless without question.”

*Note: this was previously published elsewhere. By now, new info about the Fidelius Charm has pertained to light


Peter Pettigrew, indigenous the harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling, provided to it is in a an excellent friend the James Potter (Harry’s dad), Sirius black color (Harry’s godfather and also James’ best friend) and Remus Lupin (werewolf and Defense versus the Dark arts teacher in Hogwarts college of Witchcraft and also Wizardry).

What happened in prisoner of Azkaban?

In bother Potter and the sinner of Azkaban

*
, book 3 the the HP series, we discover out the it was yes, really Peter Pettigrew who betrayed Harry’s parental (James and also Lily Potter). The rat blamed all of his crimes on Sirius black so the last was the one who gained punished by getting lifetime imprisonment in Azkaban prison.


Remus Lupin is a werewolf and the Defense against the Dark art teacher in Hogwarts institution of Witchcraft and Wizardry during Harry Potter and also the sinner of Azkaban

*
, book 3 the the HP series by J.K. Rowling.

Sirius black is the godfather of bother Potter and the ideal friend that James Potter (Harry’s dad). That was erroneously imprisoned in Azkaban because that crimes (including the killing of number of people) he didn’t commit. Why walk Remus Lupin should talk come Sirius Black? how come he didn’t do that? Let’s talk about the issue in story format:

Alfred frowned at the write-up title. “Is this concerned the last post Cy? ns don’t think I want to comment on this. It’s one insult and mockery come friendship.”


8 November 2015 06:51 amSirius Black, What Does the Feel prefer To be Blamed because that Something you Did not Do?

Sirius black is take care of Potter’s godfather and James Potter’s (Harry’s dad) ideal friend. That was very first introduced in bother Potter and the sinner of Azkaban

*
, publication 3 of the HP collection by J.K. Rowling.

Unfortunately, he lived a really tragic and sad life and also this write-up is around how he to be blamed because that crimes the he didn’t commit, exactly how he to be thrown into prison and also how nobody bothered to help him out.


Should Sirius black forgive his friends and all those that hurt, abandoned and betrayed him? Or should he look for revenge versus these people?

Sirius black color was first introduced in harry Potter and also the sinner of Azkaban

*
, book 3 that the HP series by J.K. Rowling. He’s the godfather the Harry, the protagonist, and also the finest friend the James Potter, Harry’s dad.

He was imprisoned for crimes (including the murder of a lot of people and also being the right-hand man of Dark lord Voldemort) the didn’t commit. Let’s talk about the problem in story format. The alternative title is “was Sirius black color being the end of character in this situation?”

“What instance are we talking around Cy?” Alfred asked, feather confusedly at the alternate post title.


Sirius black color is a character in the take care of Potter collection of books by J.K. Rowling. He is Harry’s (the protagonist) godfather and also the finest friend that James Potter (Harry’s dad). What occurred to him? that betrayed him? was it ideal for him to forgive all those who wronged that or can this be taken into consideration a plothole? Let’s talk about the entire issue in story format:

Alfred’s title for this post, created in his confusing handwriting the was barely legible, is: “why this doesn’t make any sense?”


Cyrus’ eye twitched together he eyed the title paper that Alfred proudly proved off come him. “You understand what doesn’t make any kind of sense?” he asked. That didn’t stroked nerves to wait because that a response. “This title.” he sighed. “This is why girlfriend shouldn’t be enabled to offer the titles.”


“Those who’ve read the take care of Potter series by J.K. Rowling will recognize that Sirius black color was not provided a trial after he to be accused the betraying the Potters (James and also Lily, Harry’s parents), being Dark lord Voldemort’s right-hand man and causing the fatality of Peter Pettigrew (a friend of James, Sirius and Remus) and a variety of muggles.

“Instead, he to be dumped in Azkaban prison without even being offered a opportunity to define himself. The question now is-” Cyrus said before he was interrupted through a distressed Alfred.

See more: Boyfriend Lost Bet What Should He Do, 12 Best Lost Bet'S Ideas

“It’s not fair, girlfriend know?” Alfred said, frowning. “Sirius need to have obtained a trial. The should have actually been provided the advantage of the doubt. He should have actually been innocent till proven guilty even if the evidence might seem stacked against him. He-”


What go Sirius black do? Why should Albus Dumbledore get him a trial? What’s wrong through the last not acquiring the former a trial?

Sirius black color was very first introduced in take care of Potter and also the sinner of Azkaban

*
, publication 3 the the HP series by J.K. Rowling. He’s Harry’s (the protagonist) godfather and also James Potter’s (Harry’s dad) finest friend. That was sent out to Azkaban jail for crimes (including the murder of a lot of people) that he didn’t commit.

Albus Dumbledore is the headmaster of Hogwarts college of Witchcraft and Wizardry however he has many other positions including being the chef Warlock that the Wizengamot. Let’s talk about the problem in story format:

“The alternative post title is ‘why didn’t headmaster Albus Dumbledore ask because that a trial for Sirius black color after he uncovered out that the latter supposedly betrayed James and Lily Potter (Harry’s parents) and caused the death of Peter Pettigrew (friend the Sirius and also James) and a many muggles?’” Alfred said, frowning. “He should have, girlfriend know? Why didn’t he?”