You are watching: Is glee appropriate for 12 year olds
“Did friend see Glee last night?”
“The music was awesome. Ns downloaded 2 of the songs on iTunes before I saw bed.”
A year later, the display would blow everything else away, v 19 Emmy nominations, much more than any other TV program. The 2010 Emmys became Glee-afied, with a memorable opened number in i m sorry Jimmy Fallon, Tina Fey, Betty White, and also other popular television stars join the Glee cast in song and also dance performing Bruce Springsteen’s “Born to Run.”
The display is now one of the most watched, most downloaded, and most talked-about TV programs among young people. The 2010 Teen choice Awards were hosted by Katy Perry and also the Glee cast. The MTV video Music Awards supplied the Glee cast to award Lady Gaga a VMA for finest pop video. Gleecharacters Rachel, Finn, Kurt, and Quinn are family names and pop-culture icons.
Each illustration is most likely one of the most an imaginative and entertaining hrs of tv on any type of given Tuesday. The storyline is hilarious however gripping, the 15 characters are both real and memorable, and the music numbers space well performed. (When i was farming up, we had Fame. Rachel is the new Cocoa.) There’s much more talent top top this actors than almost any year of American Idol’s top 10. After ~ the display airs, the songs walk on revenue on iTunes and also are automatically catapulted right into to the top 10. I’ve checked out Season 1 CDs 3 times this week at three various stores and the DVD’s on display everywhere in anticipation the the Season II Premier coming this Tuesday, September 21.
Looking because that AnswersSo, what content are young viewers absorbing from this show?
Glee deals through real issues that teens face today, showing aftermath and hurt. The authors tell it favor it is, warts and all. Name it: teen pregnancy, bullying, me image, and equal rights. However at the exact same time, the show sends mixed messages. It’s frequently coarse, laced with sexual humor, and preachy in assistance of the homosexual lifestyle. (One that the show’s writer/creators, Ryan Murphy, is gay, number of of the cast members space gay, and also the present has a huge LGBT following.)
Christian parents constantly ask me: Should i let my youngsters watch Glee?
Even though I can possibly market some guidance toward the answer to that question, ns hesitate come answer it because my an answer would negate the function behind it.
Allow me to explain: The answer to that inquiry is, Parents must assist their kids figure out for themselves if they must watch the show. The process itself is much more important than the answer. In other words, if ns or some other writer or radio personality were to merely say, “No, don’t let your kids watch it,” I’d hate to think the parents would certainly default to simply answering, “Sorry, Jonathan says ‘no,’ so that way the present is bad.”
Parenting isn’t that simple. And I don’t typical to make a cliché through that phrase. Truly, nursing is anything yet simple. The truth is, many teaching avenues take time, effort, and thought. And if parents are truly living the end that Deuteronomy 6 passage (Love the LORD your God with all your heart and also with all your soul and with all your strength. This commandments that I offer you today room to it is in upon your hearts. Admire them on your children. Talk about them once you sit at home and when you walk follow me the road, when you lie down and also when you get up… Deuteronomy 6:5-7, NIV), then we’ll be dialoging constantly through our kids about the influences around them, the temptations they face, and also the decisions they make. This conversations will need a most guidance v younger kids, gradually leading to more freedom as they obtain older. After all, once they’re 18…it’s really up to them, isn’t it?
This means that my 15-year-old and 17-year-old might be able to discern right and wrong in a situation far better than my 13-year-old. Critical month Alec, my 17-year-old, and also I watched a movie together. ~ the movie he called me, “Dad, ns think the filmmaker was trying to make the main character a hero, yet I had actually a problem with a lot of what the did.” Alec go on to name several negative decisions he it was observed from the key character. Ns asked him just how he knew those decisions to be bad. Before we knew it, us were talking around biblical principles.
As us walked by some movie posters in the theatre, we had conversations about other films and also why we would certainly or would not watch them. That conversation demonstrated that Alec is on his way toward make some an excellent media decision on his own.
In contrast, my 13-year old, Ashley, heard a Lady Gaga tune while us were walking through Wal-Mart and also commented, “She’s bad, right Dad?” ns asked her why she figured Lady Gaga is “bad.” Ashley said, “Because she’s a freak!” Funny as that was, she couldn’t offer me one example of why Gaga is “bad.” From the comment and others choose it, ns realized the Ashley’s not all set to make a most media options on her own.
We have to teach our kids to think biblically about the media they encounter. They require to understand what distracts lock from your relationships v God, and also what help them attract closer come God. Our kids don’t need a Gaga…bad, Lil Wayne…bad, Toby Mac…good list.
All Good, all BadWhat about Madonna—good or bad? Okay, now what around Amy Grant—good or bad? Easy, right? The kosher Christian an answer is that Madonna is, that course, bad, and also Amy approve is good. Duh!
Oops. Organize on a sec! (Shhh. Don’t spread this around, but Amy Grant obtained a…divorce! So, currently is Amy approve bad, too?)
Where do we gain off make those judgments? Yesterday i gossiped about somebody. (Honestly, ns did, just yesterday. Yes sir a woman that drives me—and a the majority of people—nuts, and also we discovered out she’s moving down the street indigenous a friend of ours. I made jokes to that friend around how “lucky” they were to have actually her because that a neighborhood now! We had actually a an excellent laugh.)
As shortly as i hung up, ns knew what I’d done. Ns gossiped, slandered…you name it. The scriptures has hundreds of references to this sort of activity, constantly with the words, “Have nothing to do with…” put in front of it.
Yet, ns did.
I guess mine daughter have to ask mine wife, “Mom, is Dad bad?” Lori would have to respond, “Yes. In fact, we all are. We all need Jesus!”
That’s simply it. We’re every bad. You should actually protect against reading this article right now since the author is bad.
Or, far better yet, possibly we need to stop calling world in the media “bad” or “good” and also start reasoning biblically around our media-usage decisions. In other words, “Should i watch HBO’s True Blood?” Well, what does the bible say about it?
I tried 15 minute of True Blood once in a hotel on one of my speak trips. In the 15 minutes ns saw two graphic sex scenes and enough sensuality come jump start a Ford Pinto. (And many Pintos are beyond the assist of jumper cables.) So, need to I watch True Blood? In 1 Corinthians, Paul speak me to literally “flee” sex-related immorality. If I happen to view other civilization having sex on TV for much longer than it takes me to avert my eye and adjust the channel, I recognize for a reality I’m no fleeing sexual immorality. Frankly, the just question I have actually is, “Why no I revolve off True Blood sooner than 15 minutes?”
Case closed. Utilizing biblical reasoning, True Blood isn’t because that me.
So what about Glee?
Thinking Biblically about GleeI watched the pilot episode of Glee, Season I with my 15-year-old daughter. The display was tame by comparison to much of those on TV. No sex, nothing really profane—in fact, fairly the opposite. The pilot episode verified real kids facing hard decisions and taking a stand for those right.
In one scene, Finn, a quarterback, was tempted by his football buddies to bully a handicapped Glee society kid. Finn not only stands approximately his misguided teammates but joins the Glee Club regardless of what others would think of him. Finn tells Glee members Rachel and Kurt around his decision. The dialogue in that scene is an effective and humorous:
FINN: I don’t want to it is in the man that just drives approximately throwing egg at people.
RACHEL: That was you?!
KURT: You and your friend threw pee balloons at me.
FINN: I know.
KURT: You nailed all my lawn furniture to my roof.
FINN: I wasn’t in reality there for that…but I’m yes, really sorry. Look, that isn’t who I am, and I’m exhausted of it. This is what I want to it is in doing, with you guys. I supplied to think that
I had actually no difficulties with the pilot illustration at all. Ns actually think it provoked good discussion around self esteem, bullying, and doing what’s right, also when it costs you popularity.
Unfortunately the rest season no so tame. The 2nd episode, titled “Showmance,” gives a quite authentic portrayal the the struggle the Glee Club kids face trying come fit in. Fearing rejection, castle don’t desire to perform a corny musical number in former of the school. Therefore Rachel has an idea.
RACHEL: I have an additional idea for the assembly. We’re going to provide them what they want. Sex.
The next scene is the assembly, and the Glee society is introduced. The members execute a ridiculously raunchy dance routine to Salt-N-Pepa’s late-80s hip-hop hit, “Push It.” The scene to be absolutely hilarious, really making fun of how risqué student-run performances deserve to be. And also believe me, the was much more accurate the you may realize. Cheerleaders at my high institution performed a sexualized dance routine to that very song in the late 80s and also caused community outrage.
Mr. Schuester, the teacher in fee of the Glee Club, had actually a word with the youngsters after the sexualized performance:
MR. SCHUESTER: I know how much girlfriend care around Glee Club. And also I understand why girlfriend did what girlfriend did. However I don’t prefer the means that girlfriend did it.
In another episode Puckerman is urged by his mom to find a nice Jewish girlfriend, so he begins pursuing Rachel. So he and also Rachel get alone in a bedroom to practice music, and also Puckerman’s voice-over narrates: “Rachel to be a warm Jew, and also the great Lord wanted me to gain into her pants.” so Puckerman asks Rachel, “Wanna make out?” to which she responds, “Sure.” and also they start rolling on the bed kissing. Rachel stops it after ~ a couple of seconds, questioning Puckerman around his life choices.
As i watched this scene alone, ns thought, I’m glad Ashley
Glee also has two cheerleaders, Brittany and also Santana, who are obviously exploring in same-sex relationships. The present has made subtle references to them having sex together, and also in one illustration the two of castle walk hand in hand and ask Finn out on a date—the 3 of them. This pales in compare to numerous other TV shows (looking for a ratings boost) that show on-screen threesomes and bi-curious teenagers acting out, but the subtle blog post is clear.
Yes, Glee is messy. The morality isn’t black and white. In one moment it encourages viewers to love others, but in the following they’re watching a risqué run routine. The display is filled with our culture’s thinking and also reasoning, both good and bad.
Is that true? Is the content real? In other words, Are the show’s creators lying to us?
Again, an extremely messy. ~ above one hand, Glee espouses great values around caring for world who’re different—a biblical principle, indeed; however it additionally proclaims that homosexuality is natural and should it is in embraced—clearly versus biblical teaching. Glee touches top top the subject of authenticity and also lying when Finn requirements a job to aid his pregnant girlfriend Quinn, however he lies (posing as a disabled person) to get the job. And…no consequences. So, does that mean Glee endorses lying? once Tina lies come Artie about her lisp, Artie no seem come think lying is acceptable; the takes that a lengthy time to forgive Tina. Certainly consequences. Therefore is the taboo to lie to friends, yet okay to lie come “the man”?
Will our kids address these issues and struggles in the genuine world? Absolutely. Therefore now, parents have actually two polar clues of see to consider:
1. Wouldn’t it be better for our youngsters to encounter this sorts the philosophies and also worldviews and also values through us sitting next to them ~ above the couch so us can talk about the show’s content through them afterward?
2. Perform we really desire our kids absorbing this stuff?
No doubt, Glee is continuously Grade-A prime fodder because that provoking discussion. No long right into the season, Quinn—one the the Glee club members and president that the Celibacy club (a actual club in the show; plainly a jab at Christians)—gets pregnant. This creates quite a stir and is encountered in number of episodes. If Quinn is kicked off the cheerleading squad, Glee club members take on her. Additionally, she rejected by her “Christian” parents…but embraced by Finn’s mom.
So, for youth workers and parents whose kids are currently watching Glee, I encourage friend to watch it with them and also dialogue through them around the plenty of topics the covers each week. If you’re a parent who’s trying to decide whether or no to permit your children watch the show, the decision is really up to you. But make sure you ago it up with biblical truth. I promise you, if friend raise your kids with as well many, “Because I said so, it is why!” reasons, then your children could rebel. I’ve seen it happen just like that means too often.
Looking for Biblical GuidanceChristians constantly seem to quote Philippians 4:8 together a catch-all verse about what’s “good” and what’s “bad”:
Finally, brothers, every little thing is true, every little thing is noble, everything is right, every little thing is pure, everything is lovely, every little thing is admirable—if anything is wonderful or praiseworthy—think around such things. (NIV)
You can not argue through the beauty and also truth in that verse, yet I don’t understand if the the ideal one once it comes to backing up our decisions to rule versus our youngsters digesting particular media. Specifics yes, it’s great to think about praiseworthy things…but go watching Glee actually save you native thinking around praiseworthy things? one affirmative an answer would it is in a hard one to defend. So, let’s rather look at the entirety of the Scriptures—not simply one passage—to connect truth.
I believe Colossians 3 go a step additional than the Philippians verse, encouraging united state to collection our psychic on things above, not earthly things. It even provides a perform of stuff we should “rid ourselves” of and also what our “new self” watch like when we enable Christ come take regulate of ours lives.
The an ext you dive into God’s word as a family, the more you’ll find passages that burned light top top day-to-day decision-making.
Recently our household finished 1 man together. (We try to check out the bible together ~ dinner a few times a week.) ~ its reminders around what oh my gosh love looks prefer in us, in addition to its speak to to obedience, 1 man ends v this verse:
Dear children, keep yourselves indigenous idols. (5:21, NIV)
But I taken place to it is in referencing the new Living Translation when I read it through my kids:
Dear children, save away native anything that could take God’s ar in your hearts. (5:21, NLT)
That said, I’m not claiming that Glee will take it God’s ar in her kids’ hearts. But we do must be careful of distractions.
Steering clean of Harmful ContentI mentioned my 13-year-old earlier and her attempt to discern even if it is Lady Gaga was ideal or not. Mine daughter is smarter than I’m probably giving her credit transaction for, but she’s additionally a sponge, absorbing information all around her and trying to discern reality from lies. Her emotions are in high gear, and everything in she life is “drama” best now. (She’s currently observing peers “living for temporary thrills,” therefore I want to make sure to saturate her with as much reality as possible.)
The American Academy that Pediatrics just exit (August 30) that is brand brand-new study, Sexuality, Contraception, and also the Media. This report examines media messages teens are absorbing and how those influences influence their well being. In other words, as soon as my daughters watch Glee, does it make them want to make out with their boyfriends or obtain pregnant? That’s what the AAP sought to discover. Right here are few of the truth from that research that jumped out at me:More than 75% that prime-time program contain sexual content.Only 14% that these incidents mention any kind of risks or responsibilities of sex-related activityTalk around sex top top TV can occur as regularly as 8 come 10 times every hour.Between 1997 and also 2001 alone, the quantity of sexual content ~ above TV virtually doubled.The media may duty as a “superpeer” in convincing teenagers that sexual activity is typical young-teenager behavior.Listening to sexually degrading lyrics is connected with previously sexual intercourse.Of nine researches seeking to recognize if “sexy” media contributes to at an early stage sexual activity, 7 of these studies have shown that exposure to sex-related content on TV and also other media in beforehand adolescence can as lot as double the hazard of early on sexual intercourse.Early exposure to sexual content doubles the hazard of teen pregnancy.Bedroom TVs are associated with better substance use and also sexual task by teenagers.
The AAP summary its findings well: “Clearly, the media theatre a significant role in determining whether particular teenagers become sexually energetic earlier rather than later.”
But yes sir some an excellent news native the report together well:Teenagers whose parents regulate their TV-viewing behavior are less sexually experienced.Adolescents who parents limit your TV-viewing are less likely to engage in beforehand sex.
The message from this report are loud and also clear: Media affects ours kids. For this reason parents, help your youngsters make an excellent media decisions. That’s a pretty clear mandate.
And the last is just one of numerous reports favor it. I have talked about other reports in numerous articlesand blogs. The fact is, most teenagers are absorbing means too lot sexual content in media, and it’s affecting castle big-time. Researches that show 1 in 4 American teenagers has contracted an STD are complicated to dismiss.
One thing I evaluate about Glee, however, is that it seems to typically depict the after-effects of negative decisions. Pains is a genuine emotion, and we watch it depicted often on Glee. Quinn’s pregnant is anything yet glorified. Most other shows (Two and a half Men comes come mind) are completely irresponsible in this regard. As such I think we must guard our kids from terrible messages.
It’s as much as YouSo…to Glee or no to Glee? That is the question. But if I decided on an answer for you, I’d have actually robbed girlfriend (and your kids) the the process.
The process seems to be this:
1. Get right into God’s Word. Find methods for your totality family come bathe in biblical truth so they obtain solid foundations for handling media choices. ~ all, how can they think biblically if lock don’t recognize the Bible?
2. Consider your age. Should we talk v our kids around mature topics (e.g., sex and drugs) as soon as they’re still young? Absolutely. Never ever hold ago the truth. At the exact same time, however, guard them native the media’s lies. Our boys space becoming desensitized and our girls room becoming sexualized way too soon. Which leads me come my last point…
3. Watch the end for the media’s lies. Consider the just-mentioned AAP report that also reveals only 14 percent of TV programs revolving approximately sexual content mention any risks or duties tied to sex-related activity. So, walk this typical turn off all media? No. But teach discernment. Co-watch with your kids and also talk around what friend saw. Use the stop button and discuss problems as they happen.
Last week ns asked my blog subscribers to chime in v their 2 cents on their opinions about Glee. I request the question, “Should our children watch it?” The comments in the blog are fascinating, with countless points of view.
See more: Jeep Grand Cherokee Towing Capacity 2006 Jeep Grand Cherokee Towing Capacity
Almost all the comments seem to have one typical denominator—the same usual denominator I’ve checked out from most of the reports and also opinions around kids’ exposure come media: Parents, talk v your kids about influences prefer this.