Riddles space a good way to pass the time when traveling. Specifically if you are up in the air in a aircraft and don’t have actually internet accessibility for a while.

You are watching: How many daughters does mr smith have

It’s much too easy these work for civilization to google the answer come riddles instead of do the efforts to figure them out! that kinda loss the function of a riddle if you just look up the answer.

Today we’re looking at the “Mr Smith had actually 4 Daughters” riddle. Below it is declared in it’s most typical format.

Mr smith had 4 daughters, each daughter had a brother. Just how many kids does grandfather Smith have?

The puzzle likewise takes a couple of different forms:

Mr.Smith has 4 daughters. Each of his daughters has a brother. Exactly how many youngsters does grandfather Smith have?Mr. Blacksmith had 4 daughters. Each daughter had 4 brothers. Just how many children does Mr. Blacksmith have?Mr blacksmith has four daughters. Each daughter had 4 brothers. how many youngsters does grandfather Smith have?Mr and also Mrs Smith have actually 4 daughters…

The answer to the “Mr Smith had actually 4 daughters” riddle is…

Wait… perform you really desire to provide up?

The prize Explained

The riddle tries come make united state think there are 8 kids. 4 daughters and also 4 brothers.

Here’s candid on Twitter virtually getting the wrong.

Diana explained how she witnessed it.

When people use google to shot to get response to this riddle a proportion kind things prefer this:

“mr smith had actually 4 daughers 4 brothers”“mr smith had 4 daughters, each daughter had 4 brothers”

The original riddle never ever mentions “4 brothers”. The cheat of the riddle hangs upon this mistaken assumption that there are 4 various brothers, one for each sister. Over there is only one brother!

The alternative Dark Explanation “Had” Or “Has”

I believe the answer given above is the to plan answer to the riddle. It’s not as facility as some people make out.

The trick is in making girlfriend think there are four brothers and that there will certainly be 8 youngsters in total.

However over there is lot debate around what the real answer to this riddle is. That revolves about the meaning of the word “had”.

The alternate answer is that since Mr smith “had” 4 daughters it was something that remained in the past and also that it means Mr blacksmith no longer has actually 4 daughters or a child in the present.

They then conclude the it method the genuine answer come the riddle is that Mr Smith has no children presently.

Let’s look in ~ the an interpretation of the word “had”.

If you heard the a Mrs smith “had a baby” you wouldn’t think the a baby was born and also subsequently died. Hearing the “she had a baby” is good news!

If the riddle was “Mrs Smith had actually 4 daughters” climate you’d think it expected she “had 4 babies”. You’d be making use of “had” in the sense of undergoing an experience quite than possession.

I don’t believe the usage of had in the riddle method that the kids are all dead. The civilization isn’t the dark for me.

That grandfather & Mrs blacksmith “had” a daughter doesn’t average that the daughter is no longer around.

The Bottom Line

In truth, there isn’t sufficient information offered in the grandfather Smith daughter riddle to determine just how many children Mr blacksmith has.

The cheat of the simple riddle is that us count the brother multiple times and arrive at 8 children instead that 5.

See more: 2002 Chevy Malibu Cabin Air Filter ? 2002 Chevrolet Malibu 3

I don’t think the “had” vs “has” discussion is valid.

My own mommy “had” a son in 1978, that doesn’t average that I’m dead today. I’m still an extremely much alive and also kicking!